young man sitting on bench in park with vr headset

Everyone Wants Reality. Until It Gets In The Way.

Originally Published at American Thinker™ November 13, 2026

One of the more fascinating aspects of business and financial commentary is how frequently it overlaps with politics. Particularly when those responsible for making decisions begin explaining unfavorable outcomes without considering whether their original assumptions were incorrect.

There’s almost always an explanation. Conditions changed unexpectedly. The timing was unfortunate. Some unforeseen development disrupted an otherwise sound policy.

Any of these explanations might be legitimate. The problem begins when they become the standard response to every disappointing result, regardless of the evidence.

Years ago, Robert Ringer discussed the distinction between reality as people would prefer it to be and reality as it actually exists in his book Winning Through Intimidation. It’s an observation I’ve found particularly relevant when examining how political leaders, institutions, and their supporters respond when circumstances contradict their expectations.

Nearly everyone acknowledges the importance of understanding reality. Yet an astonishing number of politicians conduct themselves as though reality should somehow accommodate their preferences.

Consider an incumbent addressing voters about deteriorating infrastructure, rising living costs, and employment conditions that aren’t nearly as favorable as the latest GDP report might suggest.

The problems are acknowledged, followed by assurances that economic growth will accelerate, affordability will improve, and the policies responsible for producing these outcomes remain precisely what’s needed going forward.

One might reasonably wonder whether the policies have been reconsidered or merely the talking points defending them.

This isn’t an argument about Left versus Right. Nor is it an argument for change simply because someone dislikes the political party responsible.

It’s about what happens when political conviction becomes a substitute for judgment.

When Being Wrong Becomes Too Expensive

Politics is a business in more ways than most care to acknowledge. Campaigns involve substantial capital, professional management, institutional relationships, and promises that eventually need to produce something resembling the results advertised.

But unlike a private business, political initiatives frequently involve resources supplied by people who never agreed with the original proposition.

Consider today’s growing enthusiasm for data centers.

A governor or local administration announces that a major technology company intends to construct an enormous facility in the region. The project is presented as an economic-development triumph. Jobs will be created, tax revenues will increase, and the community will supposedly become a significant participant in the technological future.

Sounds wonderful.

Then residents begin asking questions.

How many permanent jobs will actually be created once construction is completed? What happens to electricity costs? Who pays for additional infrastructure? How much water will the facility require? And what tax concessions were necessary to attract the investment?

Those aren’t unreasonable questions. They’re precisely the questions that should have been answered before the project was announced as an unquestionable success.

Suppose the residents decide the economic benefits don’t justify the costs. What happens next? Does political leadership reconsider the arrangement? Or does it begin explaining why the public simply doesn’t understand the opportunity?

Initially, we’re told the benefits haven’t been communicated effectively. Fair enough. Then additional studies, promotional campaigns, and public consultations are introduced to educate those who remain unconvinced.

But here’s the question: At what point does persuading the public become more important than determining whether the public’s objections are correct?

There’s a distinction. And it’s a big one.

The Convenient Business Of Economic Success

GDP and employment statistics provide another illustration.

A political administration announces that the economy is growing and employment remains strong. Wonderful. But what exactly does that tell the individual whose household expenses continue rising faster than their income?

Or the community celebrating hundreds of construction jobs tied to a development that will employ comparatively few people once operational?

There’s nothing inherently wrong with temporary employment or economic expansion. Nor does a rising GDP automatically mean the underlying growth is artificial or undesirable. The problem emerges when broad economic statistics are presented as conclusive evidence that specific policies are benefiting the people they’re supposed to serve.

A rising GDP figure doesn’t necessarily demonstrate improving household prosperity. An increase in employment doesn’t automatically establish that the jobs created are sustainable, sufficiently compensated, or economically productive over time.

Those distinctions matter.

Yet political commentary frequently treats whichever statistic supports the prevailing narrative as proof that the policy is working.

And when the numbers become unfavorable? Suddenly, we’re reminded that economic conditions are complicated, data requires context, and the real benefits will emerge somewhere down the road.

Funny how context becomes indispensable only when the results become inconvenient.

When Agreement Becomes More Valuable Than Accuracy

This is where politics can become particularly dangerous.

A business executive defending an unsuccessful strategy may ultimately face shareholders, creditors, or customers unwilling to continue financing the experiment.

Political institutions operate under different incentives.

An initiative can remain alive because abandoning it would constitute an admission of failure. Funding continues because commitments have already been made. New explanations emerge because the original promises have become increasingly difficult to reconcile with actual results.

And those questioning the policy are no longer simply disagreeing with its merits.

They’re supposedly opposing progress, economic development, job creation, or whatever virtue has become attached to the initiative.

The irony is difficult to overlook.

An elected official can campaign on accountability and public representation, then treat public opposition as an obstacle to be overcome rather than information deserving consideration.

Eventually, defending the policy becomes more important than evaluating it. And the people financing the undertaking discover that their objections are welcome only when they support the predetermined conclusion.

Quite the definition of representative government.

Reality Doesn’t Require A Majority Vote

None of this suggests that every unpopular policy is wrong. Sometimes leadership requires pursuing difficult decisions whose benefits aren’t immediately apparent.

Nor does public opposition automatically establish that a proposal lacks merit.

But there must be some identifiable standard by which the policy can be evaluated beyond whether its supporters remain committed to defending it.

What evidence supports continuing? What would justify changing direction? Which promised benefits have materialized, and which remain projections?

More importantly, who bears the consequences if the original assumptions prove incorrect?

Because that’s the distinction that too often disappears from political debate.

We’ve developed a culture in which confidence is mistaken for competence, disagreement is treated as obstruction, and defending a policy becomes proof that the policy deserves defending.

It doesn’t.

An initiative doesn’t become economically sound because a governor announces it. A development doesn’t become beneficial because a company promises jobs. And a policy doesn’t become successful because its supporters can produce statistics suggesting otherwise.

The question is whether those responsible are willing to reconsider their decisions when the evidence no longer supports the original assumptions.

Acknowledging reality requires relatively little. Allowing it to change what we do can require considerably more.

And reality has a rather persistent habit of asserting itself — with or without the approval of the voters.

Or the politicians who claim to represent them.

© 2026 Mark St. Cyr

Disclaimer: The content published across MYTR reflects opinions, analysis, and perspective.
It is not trading nor financial advice of any sort and should never be confused with such. It is offered to inform thinking and encourage consideration – not to provide instruction, direction, or individualized advice. How any idea is interpreted, evaluated, or applied remains the responsibility of the reader, listener, or viewer, as applicable. Responsibility for decisions — and their outcomes — begins and ends with the individual making them.
Please read, or re-read the “Policy Notes” page for any questions or clarifications.